Where Does My Loyalty Lie? United 1K vs. American EXP

I write this post having not flown on American in well over eight years. The few miles I have were earned through an Alaska Airlines codeshare and an AAdvantage Shopping portal mistake involving Verizon Wireless. My lifetime travel is only 24,000 miles, and *gasp* I’ve allowed some of those to expire so that I only have about 12,000 RDM today. And yet… American has become desperate enough (or wily enough) to offer complimentary status matches to United elites. This includes matches to their top-tier Executive Platinum status for those with Premier 1K status at United, and normally both companies protect their top-tier from status matches or even challenges.

Megan and I submitted our match requests a week ago, and although I didn’t get any notification, I logged on Tuesday morning and noticed that my status had been updated along with eight eVIP systemwide upgrades. I wasn’t sure at first I would get these upgrades as a new EXP even though I hadn’t actually done any of the flying, so I’m pretty happy. The following day, I got an email welcoming me to the program.

image of American Airlines EXP welcome letter

I’m pretty psyched about it, too, because I can use them on any fare–unlike the United systemwide upgrades that can only be used on mid-priced economy fares or higher. Why spend 50% more to be put on a waitlist? American has also been working to extend a few of its elite benefits to Alaska planes, which is good because nearly all flights out of Seattle are operated by Alaska, not American (e.g., SEA-SFO) or Alaska just has more convenient direct routes (e.g., SEA-LAS). So although I haven’t flown American/Alaska lately, I am likely to do so soon and may even try to keep my top-tier status with both airlines.

systemwide upgrades summary image

It bears asking how I think the two carriers measure up against each other. I have no intention of dumping my 1K status, which has worked to my benefit for the most part. I also feel that American has been overly generous with its EQM and status matches so that if I did jump ship, I might find my benefits diluted next year. For now I’m just a lucky beneficiary who had nothing to lose. But that still doesn’t mean United is perfect or that American can be completely ruled out. So here are my impressions about how the two top-tiers stack up. The Points Guy already did a similar comparison last year, although I feel it might confuse the issue at hand by including US Airways and Delta. You can also read more at the websites for American AAdvantage or United MileagePlus.

Domestic Upgrades

United places me second in line for domestic upgrades after its Global Services members, and I usually get upgraded when flying alone even on G fares. American will give me complimentary upgrades, too, although I believe I will be the first and only group that gets them. There is an invite-only Concierge Key service, but my understanding is that it applies mostly to service on the ground. And while lower tiers also get free upgrades on full-fare tickets, the same is true on United. I’d expect nothing less.

Some people complain that all the GS members on United make 1Ks second class passengers, but I’ve never felt that. GS is still a smaller group than 1K, and I would argue that since most of them got where they are by buying expensive fares, they would probably get priority on upgrades even if they were still part of the 1K pool without a GS bump.

Where things get problematic is that American does not provide companion upgrades, and I very much appreciate that United treats Megan with the same status I have. Sometimes it means we miss an upgrade because people traveling alone get bumped up before us, but that’s okay. With American, I’ll have to buy her some 500-mile upgrade certificates at a cost of $30 to $150 per domestic flight.

International Upgrades

This is where American really shines. They don’t make the upgrades impossible to use. If you want to upgrade your flight, use an upgrade. And you’ve got eight of them! That’s two round trips for Megan and I. United gives me only six that are a pain to use, and from recent reports seem to be difficult to apply as upgrade space is often lacking. United does provide four regional upgrades, while American does not, but I think the flexible systemwide upgrades are more important.

Catering and On-Board Product

United is working to improve its food. It really is. Continental had great catering so I’m told. But during the merger United let it fall even further and is only now catching up, restoring some features even as it adds new ones. American, however, keeps coming up with new things. They’ve had ice cream sundaes long before United, they never got rid of hot nuts, and the main courses I read about–even on domestic routes–make my mouth water. With United I’m just grateful for any food in first class; in economy you might not get anything at all on long routes like New York to Honolulu. Clearly American wins this one.

Both American and United offer flat bed seats in first and business class, though business class is in a state of flux. I’m not exactly sure of the status of United’s flat bed business class roll-out, but I know it’s near completion whereas American has only recently announced a revamp of its fleet that is expected to take years.

picture of business class cabin on plane

American’s new business class

American has extensive WiFi on its international and domestic routes, while United has barely any, but then again I can usually tolerate several hours without Internet access. American is also working to improve the comfort of its business class seats, including actual duvets and a spiff new seat layout. I’m not sure what United is doing, but I know that some report the new business class seats are too narrow and that the rear-facing rows freak people out. (It certainly freaked me out when I was sitting in coach staring at business class for 10 hours. I don’t know how I would feel if I were the guy staring back.)

However–and this is important–I love United’s EconomyPlus seats. American’s extra legroom product is far more limited, and should you get stuck in standard economy, some widebody planes will have 10 seats across instead of United’s nine. Since I still sit in coach often enough, these differences matter a lot.

Customer Service

I hear lots of good things about American. I also hear lots of good things about United’s 1K desk …at least I used to. I think the merger is still leaving a few things up in the air. Personally, I don’t complain that much or have complicated problems, so I’ve been satisfied (I may whine on my blog, but in real life I’m quite passive). To be fair, I can’t really weigh one way or the other on this issue.

Route Networks and Alliance Partners

Finding award space, in my opinion, is much easier on United since they include all partners in their online search engine. Yes, it’s a little buggy, but nothing like Delta. American’s partners seem to have better availability than United’s on some routes, but I think this is all partner-specific and not United or American’s fault. I’m of the opinion that the quality of these partners’ products is more or less the same. United has some very, very good partners in the Star Alliance like Swiss and Singapore, but American has some good ones, too. I don’t see any reason to make this issue a dividing one.

As for the actual destinations, United is huge and goes to many more places. American doesn’t, but it has its regional strengths. I think American realizes it can rely on its partners for many of its holes, and while that may work in some ways, it does have drawbacks as far as the use of systemwide upgrades is concerned. I like the idea of having top-tier status in both programs partly because each airline focuses on different routes. Connections are great when you want to rack up extra miles, but sometimes you really just don’t have the time.


This is the big one that determines whether it’s feasible for me to maintain my status with both carriers. It turns out that American is very affordable if you play your cards right. United provides almost no discount opportunities and has even gotten tight with compensation. American, however, regularly offers discount codes, and you can even find public conference codes for 5-10% off if you look around on the Internet. Costco sells $300 American Airlines gift cards for only $270. You could even buy that gift card with an Amex prepaid card from Office Depot that you purchased with a Chase Ink Bold for 5X Ultimate Rewards points. Finally, there are also lots of 2X RDM/EQM promos (at least lately) to help you reach your goals without flying as much.

picture of American Airlines giftcard

If you value the UR points at 2 cents, then combining the Costco and Ink Bold deals would earn you a 20% discount on all American Airlines travel. Combine it with a conference or other discount code, and you can turn that into a 25-30% discount on most travel.


The financials of being an American elite are great, particularly for upgrading international travel or when I really must have a direct domestic flight. I just still can’t see myself flying them regularly with a companion, and most of my travel continues to be to United hubs like San Francisco, Houston, and Washington, DC. It will ultimately boil down to time. I can see myself racking up 50K EQM or more through upgraded international trips with Megan, but beyond that, I may have to do some serious mileage running to keep up the status for another year. And that is where the DEQM promos will start to come in handy. Let’s hope they stick around through fall and winter!

Rewarding Recap: Lounge Lizards, Hyatt Status, and Priority Club Points + Rebates
Final Opportunity for Free Hyatt Platinum (Use to Earn Extra Club Carlson Points)
  • BandolRose

    Thanks for this info- I’m a United 1K flyer and appalled at the changes and poor service since the transition and would like to do an AA status match. Is there a specific link or department to contact to get the ball rolling? I’ve done similar requests with hotels (used my Marriott Platinum status to gain Club Carlson status) with good success.

  • Rezvi

    hi what was the date you send the documents in and was it just your 1k card

    • BandolRose

      I haven’t started the process yet but found a related posting on another site that mentioned the email below- just not sure if thats the best approach aadvantage_customer_svc@wwwmail.aa.com.

      • Scottrick

        The instructions I got were to call first, and then Customer Service would send you an offer email to which you reply with your current UA account info. I would not recommend sending an unsolicited email without calling.

    • Scottrick

      Took about two weeks exactly.

  • Ikonos


    Have you done any analysis of premium award and cheap fare availability from SEA/PDX/YVR on United and American? I will be interested in that analysis and I think it helps PNW fliers make up their mind. I am a DL DM and can bank enough rollover MQM by the end of the year to be PM at least for the next two years. I am seriously thinking of switching to UA or AA next year as I like premium international travel out of PNW.

    Have you found any Office Depot in SEA area with the reloadable gift cards to load Amex PrePaid card?


    • Scottrick

      As usual, Ikonos asks lots of good questions. (1) I have not done an analysis, but I would be willing to work on one. IME, W fares on UA to Europe or Asia are about $1,500, but this is anecdotal and not something I’ve examined seriously.

      (2) If you are trying to do a match, I have no idea how UA or AA would respond to a request from a DL DM. Both have historically protected their top tiers. AA seems to have opened up a bit, but my impression is that this current offer is only open to UA members upset with the merger, not other programs. Given rumored changes to DL and the fact you have so many rollover MQM, you might get a different response.

      (3) I have gotten an Amex prepaid card from my local Office Depot near U Village, and the permanent card arrived Wednesday. No problem there. I have not tried reloading it with a Vanilla card. I plan to try that this weekend. I also need to go hunt for Amazon gift cards, but Office Max is way on the other side of town in Ballard, and the excellent weather this weekend suggests massive traffic jams if people head to Golden Gardens.

  • http://twitter.com/kziel Kris Ziel

    All my flights in the new United business class (including the 17 hours flight from ORD to HKG, which at the time was the longest UA flight), have been in backward facing seats. I really don’t understand the complaints in the slightest. Not that it matters, because the chance of a crash is about 0, but backward facing seats are far safer, other than that, there is no noticeable difference.

    • Scottrick

      I’m not worried about safety at all. Really, the chance of a crash is virtually non-existent. I’m just saying that it’s weird to look backwards and see someone else facing you. It’s hard not to stare. I was in the bulkhead row of coach and saw EVERYTHING this one guy and his wife did in their rear-facing seats in the last row of business.

  • http://www.facebook.com/joanne.busansky Joanne Litt Busansky

    Great analysis, For me it come down to cost and service, and in my view its no contest- AA wins.  I admit, I may be biased,  i am lifetime gold, almost platinum- but I have had UA status on and of with UA too.  American just gets better and better. They may not have the cushiest fleet, but they  seem to have the best people.I think thats why  why AA did so well at the Freddies- The CSAs are top rate and will stay on the phone looking every which way to find an award seat for you. It is just rare to have a bad experience. United on the other hand…. well “what have you done for me lately?” seems to be the way you get treated. 

    So I would encourage anyone considering American to give them a try-  writing this response got me thinking, If we all rallied around this airline and gave them more of our business  we would help them get stronger, emerge from bankruptcy, even remain independent. And in the long run another airline merger is probably not the best thing for any of us. We could start a movement……….

    • http://twitter.com/kziel Kris Ziel

      In the six or seven times I have called United this year, the agent has not had a “what have you done for me lately?” attitude, it has been an “is there anything else I can do for you” attitude.

  • http://twitter.com/aadvantageGeek AAdvantage Geek

    Wow, I read about the status match and wondered if AA was going to include the system wide upgrades. I’m like Joanne in that I want AA to succeed, so I’m glad to see them try to compete for new customers.   

    Great analysis.  It’s interesting to see how the AAdvantage program compares UA.  

  • EsquireFlyer

    Can you really save 10% by using a giftcard? Doesn’t buying the giftcard at Costco add a layer of sales tax to the transaction, which in most states ins 6%-9%, thus wiping out most of the gift card discount (even before you count the transportation cost to get to Costco)?

    • Scottrick

      I don’t pretend to know what things are like everywhere in this country, but I have never seen sales tax applied to gift cards in my experience. There is usually an activation fee for pre-paid AmEx or Visa cards, but this is charged by the retailer and is always waived for merchant-specific gift cards like Starbucks, American Airlines, etc. Purchasing a gift card is just a way of committing your money to a specific retailer, not a “real” purchase in itself. You haven’t bought a good or service yet, so there’s no tax until you buy a ticket.

  • Pingback: Mid-2012 Elite Status Update - Travel Codex()