Why Does Hotel WiFi Suck?

Waiting out a long delay at Denver’s United Club, I perused its collection of free magazines. One article that caught my attention was “Why oh WiFi” in the November issue of Business Traveler by Rose Dykins. It provided the best explanation I’ve seen for why hotel WiFi is often horrible, either because the hotel charges for what seems like a basic utility or because the signal quality is so poor.

The first reason is that hotels want to make money. Duh. But they aren’t trying to add a new revenue stream. Rather they are trying to replace the loss of in-room telephone billing. As fewer people used the phone (and I’m sure the rise of mobile phones played a part) hotels raised their prices and scared away even more people.

I can’t remember the last time I used an in-room phone to do anything other than call the front desk or housekeeping. Charging for WiFi, which people do use (apparently 80% of guests at one London hotel) is a substitution for that lost revenue.

Second, the installation costs of in-room WiFi are enormous, and this is why you’ll often find hotels that offer free WiFi in the lobby but not in guest rooms. Remember that access points have limited reach, and providing poor quality service is almost worse than providing none at all. It better be good. In fairness, it is not nearly as expensive as installing and maintaining phone service, but it still isn’t cheap.

A hotel can cover its lobby with two or three access points, especially if it has minimal obstructions. But a separate wireless access point is required for every four or five guest rooms. Also, guest rooms have more electronic devices that might interfere with a wireless signal. Old tube-style televisions are one example but are well on the way out.

These facts lead me to make a reasonable excuse for the difference between budget hotels that often have free WiFi and high-end properties that charge despite their much higher rates. My experience has been that most of those high-end hotels are much larger, so the roll-out cost of providing service to more rooms is greater.

They may also have more business customers or guests with higher incomes who can afford lots of iPhones and iPads. That creates a significant load on the network. That London property I mentioned earlier has increased the size of its network connection 100-fold since it began providing service several years ago.

Contrast that with budget properties. Hyatt Place, Hampton Inn & Suites, and Holiday Inn Express tend to have very boring and regular floor plans with smaller rooms. There may only be 50 to 100 rooms in the entire building with between two and four floors. Setting up and maintaining a WiFi network is relatively simple.

Most people expect hotels to include WiFi service in their room rates at some point as a normal cost of doing business. Until that time, choosing certain hotel brands (or independent hotels) and acquiring elite status are some of the best ways to avoid paying. Business Traveler provides a cheat sheet to hotel loyalty programs that offer free Internet access, which I’ve paraphrased and augmented here.

Free with Membership:

  • Fairmont – Membership to the Presidents Club loyalty program is free and includes free Internet access.
  • Joie de Vivre – Most properties have free Internet already, but membership to the Joy of Life Club is free and includes free Internet access.
  • Kimpton – Membership to InTouch is free and includes free Internet access.
  • Omni – Membership to the Select Guest loyalty program is free and includes free Internet access.
  • Wyndham – Membership to the ByRequest loyalty program is free and includes free Internet access.
  • Group Rates – Special rates for members of AAA, certain corporations, and other groups sometimes include free WiFi in the rate description.

Free with Elite Status:

  • Hyatt – Free Internet for Platinum members of the Gold Passport program, which takes 15 nights or 5 stays. You can get “free” Platinum status with a United MileagePlus Club credit card or Hyatt Visa credit card from Chase.
  • Hilton – Free Internet for Gold members of Hilton HHonors, which takes 36 nights or 16 stays. You can get “free” Gold status with the Hilton HHonors Reserve credit card from Citi.
  • Loews – Free Internet for Blue members of YouFirst, which takes 2 stays.
  • Starwood – Free Internet for Platinum members of Starwood Preferred Guest, which takes 50 nights or 25 stays. Gold members can elect free Internet from a menu of check-in benefits, which takes 25 nights or 10 stays. You can get “free” Gold status with the Platinum Card or Business Platinum Card from American Express, or if you spend $30,000 each year with the SPG American Express card.
  • Marriott – Free Internet for Gold members of Marriott Rewards or Ritz-Carlton Rewards, which takes 50 nights for either program. You can get “free” Gold status with Ritz-Carlton for the first year with the Ritz-Carlton Rewards credit card from Chase.
Winners of the GoGo Internet Passes
Taking Advantage of Fifth Freedom Flights
  • Mike Nash

    Would love to see a site that tracks quality of hotel internet. Far to many have poor Wi-Fi, no wired connection and slow speeds. Or the best, when they contract it out and wash their hands of you when there is a problem and point you to a number to call.

  • BoneFishJoe

    Also SPG Gold with AX SPG card and 30K spend

  • bmvaughn

    I’ve always had great Wi-Fi at Marriott hotels. In room, I don’t recall ever having a bad signal. Good to be Gold :)

    • Scottrick

      I’ve had similar experiences. The WiFi at Hyatt, where I’m Diamond and it’s free, is usually pretty good. But at other chains where I have to pay, I tend to be disappointed.

  • Marcus

    Thanks for sharing this.The disparity in Wi-Fi quality between budget and luxury hotels didn’t seem to make sense before. Appreciate the additional research on which hotel rewards programs offer free Wi-Fi.

  • rick

    ..or maybe they should just have ethernet inside the rooms. Time to get with the times. It’s a vital amenity now, so unbundling it is just as bad as if they started charging for shower water separately.

    • Scottrick

      My computer doesn’t have an Ethernet port! I think this option only exists during the initial wiring, anyway. It is probably hard to wire for Ethernet in an older hotel after the fact.

      • rick

        if every room had ethernet, setting up a wireless access point would cost around $30 – 40, or even less if you buy them in bulk. There’s no excuse to charge for this service anymore except at bargain hotels. Definitely not $10/day that some higher end properties try to charge.

        • http://twitter.com/CelticsToGo Celtics Fan

          Could not agree more. If you already have ethernet in every room adding a access point for WiFi would not cost more than $50 per room. Thus, no excuses for not providing a decent WiFi in the room.

  • Diana Wu

    Thanks for the info!

  • PH

    Larger hotels should have proportionately more rooms and more revenue over which to amorize the greater initial capital expenditure and the greater ongoing operational costs as smaller hotels. Accepting that “larger means greater cost” as an excuse is pretty uncritical thinking.

    • Scottrick

      I think it’s still a possibility, but I never said it was the only one. Amortizing costs is one way to justify an investment. You still need to have the money up front. That’s easy when you’re working with a smaller property or a new construction (like many budget chains). It’s not so easy when working with a larger or established property.

      The only other argument I can think of is that more expensive properties believe they have a better chance of extracting additional revenue out of high-end customers. But customers with more money are also more flexible and willing to defect to competitors, so it doesn’t seem good enough to be the only reason the disparity between budget and luxury hotels has lasted this long.

  • Jim l

    I bring my own router and plug it in where there is an Ethernet connection. It is very compact and the quality of service is greatly improved. I’ve noticed the same hotel can have good or bad service depending on the room.

    • Erica Layton

      Are there any hotels that offer a complimentary wireless router you can bring to your room to cover that “dead” patch in the signal?

      • Scottrick

        I’m not aware of any specifically. I wouldn’t be surprised if some nicer properties had one just in case. The issue is that a router only helps you if there is a wired Ethernet connection. In that case, you could have a great connection as long as you’re willing to sit at the desk (which I’m happy to do). If Wi-Fi is the only option, then there’s nowhere for the router to plug in and fill in the gap.

        • s33234

          There is no way on God’s green earth I would let a guest have one of my routers. NO WAY. You’d never see it again or it would be broken. Guests can barely connect their laptop, I’m going to trust them with a router?

  • snooploop

    If you want to use most of the Hotels WiFi with paying only one price I can recommend you the monzoon world flat product. It connects you to over 1 Million hotspot automatically for a reasonable price. http://monzoonworldflat.com/ I use it when I am travelling and it works perfectly in europe and us. Unfortunately I had some problems in Afrika.

  • http://craigslistlocations.com/ JustAnotherKnowItAll

    haha…. Please! The is nothing remotely expensive about setting up WiFi in a hotel.

  • being.chinmay

    Very helpful. I’m
    just starting out and it’s cool to know there are some people out there who
    dedicate time to giving such helpful tips.

    Fair Look | Step Up Height Increaser | Step Up Height Increaser